Blood on the Leaves.

I think Illy said it best when he said, “Please forgive me if it all sounds so familiar; I’m sure that you’ve heard this all before; I’m only one voice in a world of billions and no idea’s original no more”.

The Australian rap artist’s 2012 single focuses on the inevitability of stealing ideas and using them as your own, even unknowingly! Even with intellectual property and copyright laws as they are, it verges on impossible to say that any idea we have is completely original. It’s often said that history repeats itself and in my opinion, the same goes for ideas and art (whether it be in the form of a song, poem, story etc.)

Copyright is designed to protect those with original ideas…but what if there aren’t any original ideas left? I know that’s a fairly big call and not by any means realistic – of course there are still things yet to be discovered, melody combinations that are yet to be heard…but surely we can take old ideas and bring them to new and wider audiences?

Henry Jenkins suggests, “a world without copyright is a world without new ideas” (2004). I disagree with this, partly as an optimist and partly as a music lover. Today, artists constantly sample old tracks in their music – undoubtedly Kanye is king of this art  (and he knows it). Despite being in what seems like a constant legal battle over copyright, West cleverly takes the old and makes it new again. I’ve mentioned his work in previous blog-posts purely because it seamlessly demonstrates that people can be just as innovative using old ideas as they can be creating completely new ones.  Jenkins argues that a justification for intellectual property is that it “increases innovation and creation”. Basically, if you cant use another person’s idea, you are more likely to think up something new and better. But I put it to you, is this not innovative and creative? Is Wests’ work diminished because it is not completely original?

Clearly sampling Nina Simone’s “Strange Fruit” (1965), West effectively takes the old and makes it new, demonstrating that a world without copyright would not be the end of original ideas like Jenkins suggests. Rather it would encourage the appropriation of old material, bringing the art to wider audiences than it ever could upon its first release.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Blood on the Leaves.

  1. I love how Kanye, and many more before him, sample old classics. It shows their influences, encourages listeners to go back and check out some of these older tracks (as you mentioned) and ultimately helps immortalise them as well. It is so much of what hip-hop was built on as well. Nice post 🙂

  2. Originality is an interesting topic to focus on, here is a quote I think really fits in with your discussion. “That which has been is what will be, That which is done is what will be done, And there is nothing new under the sun.” – Ecclesiastes (Bible). I believe that individual ideas are becoming harder to come by, but like you said with the example of Kanye’s music a combination of ideas can be surprisingly original. I find copyright law to be a tricky topic to discuss. On one hand if an artists work isn’t protected they may be disinclined to create more. However copyright law can also restrict artists inspiration. I still can’t decide if I am for or against!

  3. I agree with the notion of original ideas being hard to come by. I was watching that episode of the Simpsons the other day where Homer tries to become an inventor, inspired by the likes of Thomas Edison. Turns out the only worthy things Homer invented were things he had seen and subconsciously internalised on a poster – in effect NOT inventing anything new, but improving on something old. And I feel that’s where society is at now, building upon ideas. In a developing world, surely there will be newly developed ideas, but only time will tell.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s